After many years in private practice, my
experience is that we, all of us, tend to find what we are looking
for: unconsciously. Today’s college students are looking for them and finding them everywhere. What’s underneath this current focus on micro aggressions on todays’ most exclusive college campuses? Why do so many of our so very privileged students identify as victims yet act like bullies? And what is our role as parents and grandparents in creating this mess? I think it is important to differentiate
between the over privileged and the underprivileged student in this
surprising turn of events. Most of our over privileged students have
shared some common parenting behaviors in the last two decades. They
have been protected from deprivation of any kind—never hungry, cold,
or without whatever they need. Materially, they have had almost
everything they want. They have been told with regularity that they
are exceptional. Any failure – a low grade, a lost race, forgotten homework – is immediately smoothed over by a parent. External appearances and achievement are the singular goal with very little room for experimentation. And yet, as the late psychologist Eric Erickson has written so eloquently, the essential developmental imperative for every adolescent is to find their own unique identity, something that requires experimentation and failure. So armed with a massive, sometimes heartbreaking investment in external performance, our over privileged adolescents finally win the cherished prize to prestigious colleges – with the assurance that the all nighters, the stress over maintaining perfect grades, will set them up to effortlessly succeed in not only the right college but for the rest of their lives as well. Yet even in high schools there are disturbing undercurrents, including suicide clusters. Recently, at Gunn High School in Palo Alto, Calif., Principal Denise Herrmann reported that 42 students had been hospitalized or treated for suicidal thoughts. In today’s private colleges and universities
there has been a 50 percent increase in emergency counseling
requests, a dramatic increase in more serious mental illnesses as
well as a serious jump in depression and suicidal ideation. Our
children are not doing well. We have not served them well. We send
them off to celebrate their achievements and our good parenting,
often with bumper stickers on our car proudly proclaiming, “My child
is a straight A student.” Yet at the same time, increasingly they
leave home with no inner sense of who they are. Perhaps their rage,
misguided as it is, is warranted. We have not told them the truth—we
have hidden from them life’s complexities, that they are fallible,
that fairness is not a given, and we have taught them that trying to
fix mistakes like a lower grade through manipulation is okay. In
fact, it’s something they are entitled to. I left my private practice to start a
non-profit called Summer Search to break isolation for low-income
students through offering full scholarships to summer experiential
education programs world-wide. Those programs are mostly available
to higher income students so both groups get a unique chance for a
class encounter in high school. This chance to work and live
together on wilderness trips or community service programs helped
them see beyond stereotypes, preparing them for college much
differently. This past weekend, I had a chance to sit with a group
of Summer Search alumni and listen as they talked about their
feelings of being the first and often the only one in their family
to become a college graduate. As they talked about the subtle
messages they experienced being minorities and high achievers in
their high schools and colleges, in other words micro aggressions,
it was with some pain and sadness but without anger and blame. Their
struggles of being the only minority in Advanced Placement classes,
for example, seemed to have given them a larger perspective as well
as an inner compass. About Linda Mornell Linda Mornell is the founder of Summer Search, a nonprofit organization that provides disadvantaged young people with life-changing and challenging summer opportunities. She is also the author of the book Forever Changed: How Summer Programs and Insight Mentoring Challenge Adolescents and Transform Lives. |